Every online casino and sportsbook we review gets one score out of 100. The score is the sum of five criteria with fixed weights, and the score decides one of four verdicts. Licence and legal standing carries the most weight, 30 points, because it decides who protects you when a payout is refused or an account is closed. The same rules apply to a crown site, an Ontario or Alberta licensee and an offshore brand. This page sets out those rules, shows how they play out across the 247 sites we have scored, and explains how to challenge a score you think is wrong.
The five criteria and their weights
The weights are the same for every brand and every report. None of the five criteria measures a commercial relationship with us.
- Licence and legal standing, 30 Who licenses the site, and whether a province does
- Payments and payouts, 20 Interac, Canadian dollars, published payout terms
- Player protection, 20 Limits, self-exclusion, complaints route, ownership
- Bonus fairness, 15 Wagering, caps, clarity of the terms
- Product, 15 Games, sports betting, apps
| Criterion | Points | What we look at |
|---|---|---|
| Licence and legal standing | 30 | Who licenses the site and whether a Canadian province does |
| Payments and payouts | 20 | Interac e-Transfer, accounts in Canadian dollars, written payout times, limits and verification steps |
| Player protection | 20 | Deposit and loss limits, time-outs, self-exclusion, a clear complaints route, a named company behind the site |
| Bonus fairness | 15 | Wagering multiples, maximum win or cash-out caps, game weighting, how easy the terms are to read |
| Product | 15 | Range and quality of games, sports markets and apps |
How licence points are given
A crown site, or a private operator registered with the AGCO and contracted by iGaming Ontario, or registered with AGLC and contracted by the Alberta iGaming Corporation, receives the full 30 points. Offshore licences receive fewer, because no Canadian regulator stands behind them.
- 30/30Provincial licence or crown siteAGCO and iGaming Ontario, AGLC and AiGC, or the province itself43 sites
- 14/30Malta Gaming AuthorityLicensed abroad; no provincial protection18 sites
- 12/30Kahnawake Gaming CommissionLicensed in Quebec territory, outside provincial rules14 sites
- 6/30Curacao or AnjouanLight-touch licences with weak complaint routes104 sites
- 0/30No licence foundNothing we could verify66 sites
- 30: crown site or provincially licensed operator. All 43 licensed and crown sites we have scored sit here.
- 14: Malta Gaming Authority. 18 offshore reports.
- 12: Kahnawake Gaming Commission. 14 offshore reports.
- 6: Curacao or Anjouan. 104 reports.
- 0: no licence found. 66 reports.
Two offshore reports carry figures between these steps (3 and 8). We check provincial status against the regulators’ own lists: iGaming Ontario’s directory of regulated sites (49 operators and 84 websites, accurate to 1 September 2026, read in November 2026) and AGLC’s register of gaming registrants for Alberta, whose private market opened on 13 July 2026. Offshore licences are checked against the Malta Gaming Authority’s licensee register and the Kahnawake Gaming Commission’s list of interactive permit holders. A logo in a site’s footer is not enough on its own.
Payments, protection, bonuses and product
Payments and payouts (20) reward Interac e-Transfer, accounts held in Canadian dollars and payout terms that are written down: processing times, limits and identity checks. Player protection (20) checks for deposit and loss limits, time-outs and self-exclusion, a complaints route that names who you can escalate to, and whether the company behind the site is named. Bonus fairness (15) looks at wagering multiples, caps on winnings or cash-outs, game weighting and whether the terms can be read without a lawyer. We do not publish bonus amounts or codes; this criterion is about the rules, not the size of the offer. Product (15) covers games, sports markets and apps.
Points are given for what we can confirm from a source: the operator’s terms and help pages, regulator records and app store listings. We do not claim to have tested a site with real money, and a value we could not confirm is shown as unconfirmed rather than guessed.
The four verdicts
- Recommended: 80 and above, and the site must be a crown site or provincially licensed. 18 sites today.
- Acceptable: 65 to 79. 23 sites.
- Caution: 45 to 64. 27 sites.
- Avoid: below 45. 181 sites, two of them set by hand without a score (see below).
Counts from our register today (247 scored sites). An editor can set a different verdict by hand, and the report then says why.
The licence rule is applied in the code that assigns verdicts, not by an editor’s judgement. An offshore brand that reached 80 would still be shown as Acceptable. In practice none comes close: the best offshore score on file is 57.
Brands with the status warning (fake brands, impersonation or scam adverts), closed, or not accepting Canadians receive Avoid or no score. Brands whose licence or Canadian acceptance we could not confirm are written up like offshore brands, with a plain note on what we could and could not verify. Of the 329 brands on file, 82 have no score: 68 unclear, 10 closed, 2 warning and 2 not accepting Canadians.
A worked example: BetMGM Casino
The BetMGM Casino report, last checked on 13 November 2026, is the highest score on file at 89. Here is how it adds up.

- Licence and legal standing30/30
- Payments and payouts17/20
- Player protection19/20
- Bonus fairness9/15
- Product14/15
89/100Recommended
Sum of the five lines: 89. Read the full report for the reasons behind each line.
| Criterion | Score | Points not given |
|---|---|---|
| Licence and legal standing | 30 / 30 | 0 |
| Payments and payouts | 17 / 20 | 3 |
| Player protection | 19 / 20 | 1 |
| Bonus fairness | 9 / 15 | 6 |
| Product | 14 / 15 | 1 |
| Total | 89 / 100 | 11 |
89 is above 80 and the site is licensed in Ontario, so the verdict is Recommended. Even the top score loses 6 of 15 points on bonus fairness. That pattern is common: no licensed site we have scored gets more than 10 of 15 on bonuses.
How scores spread across all sites
Licensed or crown Offshore or unclear
The 43 licensed and crown sites score between 35 and 89, with a median of 78. The 204 offshore and unclear sites score between 0 and 57, with a median of 30. The two groups barely touch. A licence is worth 30 points, but licensed sites also do better on the rest: they average 12.4 of 20 on payments and 16.4 of 20 on protection, against 6.7 and 4.4 for offshore and unclear sites. Provincial rules require limit and self-exclusion tools, so protection is where the gap is widest.
What lowers a licensed site’s score
A licence guarantees 30 points, not a good verdict. The other 70 points are earned, and 25 of the 43 licensed sites fall short of 80. Typical reasons:
- no Interac e-Transfer, or no account in Canadian dollars;
- payout times, withdrawal limits or verification steps not written down;
- protection tools that are hard to find, or no named complaints route;
- high wagering, caps on winnings, or terms that are hard to follow;
- a thin game or sports range, or no app.
The lowest licensed score on file is 247bet at 35: 30 for its licence, then 0 of 20 on payments, 0 of 20 on protection, 2 on bonuses and 3 on product. That gives it an Avoid verdict despite the licence. Lucky Liner scores 59 and sits at Caution. A licence tells you who to complain to; the score tells you how the site treats you before you need to.
Re-checks and dates
Every report shows the date it was last checked. We re-check a report when something it depends on changes: a licence granted or lost, a new payment method, new terms, or a reader’s report that a fact is out of date. A re-check reads the report against current sources, and the date on the report changes only when one has been done.
As of mid-November 2026, all 43 licensed and crown reports were last checked on 13 November 2026, and the 204 offshore and unclear reports on 29 October 2026. We do not promise a fixed cycle; the date on each report is the record.
Verdicts set by hand
An editor can set a verdict by hand instead of letting the score decide it. When that happens, the report must say why. Hand-setting is for cases the numbers cannot capture, such as a fake brand or impersonation that should carry Avoid whatever it scores. Today, all 247 scored reports carry the verdict their score gives, and two unscored brands carry an Avoid set by hand.
How to dispute a score
If you think a score or verdict is wrong, write to us through the contact page. Tell us:
- the report (its address is enough);
- the criterion or fact you think is wrong;
- a source that shows the correct position, such as a regulator page or the operator’s current terms.
We check the claim against the source, re-score the report if needed and update its date. A material change to a verdict is noted in the report. Operators use the same route as readers. Our commercial relationships do not change a score in either direction; see the affiliate disclosure. The full list of scored brands is in our reviews, and help with gambling problems is on our responsible gambling page.
Questions readers ask
- Can an offshore casino get a Recommended verdict?
No. Recommended needs a score of 80 or more and a provincial licence or crown status. Offshore licences earn at most 14 of 30 licence points, and the best offshore score on file is 57.
- Can a licensed site get a poor verdict?
Yes. A licence gives 30 points; the other 70 are earned. 247bet is licensed and scores 35, which is Avoid, and 25 of the 43 licensed sites score below 80.
- How often are scores updated?
When something a report depends on changes: a licence, payment methods, terms, or a reader's correction. Each report shows its last check date; licensed reports were last checked on 13 November 2026.
- Can an editor override the score?
An editor can set a verdict by hand and must say why in the report. Today none of the 247 scored reports is overridden; two unscored brands carry a hand-set Avoid.
- How do I dispute a score?
Write through the contact page with the report, the criterion you think is wrong and a source for the correct position. We check it, re-score if needed and update the date.
- Does an affiliate deal add points?
No. None of the five criteria measures a commercial relationship, and the weights are the same for every brand.
